Players who played for New York Yankees and New York Mets

Return to the form to edit this search or create a new search.

Are you hooked on Immaculate Grid, the daily trivia game from Baseball Reference? Whether you're looking for a little help on your grid or you already filled it out and want to know who else qualified, we have you covered. There were 163 players who played for both the New York Yankees and New York Mets.

Top Players who Played for the New York Yankees and New York Mets.

(Ranked by WAR)

Rickey Henderson

Hall of Famer Rickey Henderson played 5 seasons for the New York Yankees (30.8 WAR) and 2 seasons for the New York Mets (1.3 WAR).

Willie Randolph

Willie Randolph played 13 seasons for the New York Yankees (54.1 WAR) and 1 season for the New York Mets (0.9 WAR).

Yogi Berra

Hall of Famer Yogi Berra played 18 seasons for the New York Yankees (59.6 WAR) and 1 season for the New York Mets (-0.1 WAR).

Robinson Canó

Robinson Canó played 9 seasons for the New York Yankees (44.4 WAR) and 3 seasons for the New York Mets (1.1 WAR).

Dwight Gooden

Dwight Gooden played 3 seasons for the New York Yankees (5.1 WAR) and 11 seasons for the New York Mets (46.4 WAR).

Batting

  • 124 players batted for each of these franchises.
Batting Table
New York Yankees New York Mets
Name Yrs G AB BA HR SB WAR Yrs G AB BA HR SB WAR
Bobby Abreu2006-20083721423.29543577.0201478133.24811-0.5
Juan Acevedo200320000.01997226.00000-0.1
Jack Aker1969-197212428.07100-0.41974242.500000.1
Sandy Alomar1974-1976294931.2484462.019671522.00000-0.5
Jason Anderson2003-200530000.0200360000.0
Tucker Ashford198130000.019833556.17900-0.4
Luis Ayala201170000.02008190000.0
Harrison Bader2022-202398334.2377190.8202474233.2706131.4
Carlos Beltrán2014-20163411240.2705632.82005-20118393133.28014910031.1
Yogi Berra1946-196321167546.2853583059.6196549.22200-0.1
Ángel Berroa20092122.13600-0.720091427.14800-0.3
Dellin Betances2011-2019281.000000.02020-202110000.0
Daryl Boston19945277.18240-0.61990-1992382910.26627452.8
Darren Bragg200154.250000.020011857.263030.0
Jay Bruce20211034.11810-0.32016-2018247894.2374621.8
Miguel Cairo2004-2007257689.2696322.02005100327.251213-0.5
Robinson Canó2005-201313745336.3092043844.42019-2022168602.2692401.1
Chris Capuano2014-201521.000000.020113456.07100-0.5
Duke Carmel196568.00000-0.2196347149.235320.8
Alberto Castillo20021537.13500-0.41995-199892182.198210.6
Miguel Castro20222020-2021650000.0
Rick Cerone1980-19905871842.2493123.9199190227.273211.7
Tony Clark2004106253.2211600.22003125254.232160-0.8
Tyler Clippard2007-201772.500000.12015291.000000.0
Bartolo Colon201111.000000.02014-201690180.08310-0.9
David Cone1995-2000412.16700-0.11987-2003188399.155000.8
Billy Cowan19693248.16710-0.5196582156.17933-0.7
Ike Davis2016814.214000.02010-20144541512.2416875.7
J.D. Davis2024513.07700-0.22019-2022335960.2783751.8
Wilson Delgado20003145.244110.0200442130.292210.7
Brandon Drury20181851.17610-0.320215184.274400.2
Dock Ellis1976-197719791726.07700-0.2
Kevin Elster1994-19951737.05400-0.81986-19925371584.22434104.6
Scott Erickson200610000.0200423.000000.0
Álvaro Espinoza1988-19914471424.255783.4199648134.306400.8
Kyle Farnsworth2006-2008160000.02014170000.0
Tony Fernández1995108384.245560.9199348173.225160.2
Tim Foli198461163.25200-0.41970-1979218719.243171.1
Todd Frazier201766194.2221101.12018-2020262904.23241104.7
Bob Friend19661211.00000-0.319662229.03400-0.4
Ben Gamel201668.125000.0202466.167010.0
Karim García2002-200354156.301600.3200462192.23473-0.8
Rob Gardner1970-19722331.12900-0.21965-19664848.14600-0.1
Jesse Gonder1960-19612219.316100.21963-1965226572.2711411.9
Dwight Gooden1996-200046.00000-0.11984-1994309730.197714.8
Curtis Granderson2010-20135131859.2451155514.92014-20175732026.239952710.9
Lee Guetterman1988-199230000.01992432.000000.0
LaTroy Hawkins200820000.02013690000.0
Adeiny Hechavarría20181836.194210.0201960142.20453-0.3
Rickey Henderson1985-19895962302.2887832630.81999-2000152534.29812421.3
Sean Henn2005-200711.000000.0201340000.0
Félix Heredia2003-200450000.0200530000.0
Orlando Hernández1998-2004619.05300-0.22006-20074583.157030.1
Keith Hughes198744.00000199089.00000-0.2
Stan Jefferson19891012.08301-0.519861424.208100.1
Kelly Johnson201477201.219620.32015-2016131311.2601441.1
Lance Johnson20001830.300020.01996-1997232947.32610658.6
Dave Kingman1977824.250400.41975-19836642323.219154293.0
Brandon Knight2001-200210000.0200843.00000-0.1
Matt Lawton20052148.12521-0.4200148183.2463100.3
Tim Leary1990-199210000.01981-19842314.286110.3
Ricky Ledée1998-2000192520.25817141.32006-20074468.16221-0.3
Al Leiter1987-20051998-2004198394.08400-1.6
Cory Lidle20061997515.000000.0
Phil Linz1962-1965354968.24610124.11967-1968102316.20901-1.4
Graeme Lloyd1996-199840000.02003350000.0
Tim Locastro2021-20224764.18838-0.320234356.232260.4
Phil Lombardi1986-19872544.250200.219891848.22910-0.2
Terrence Long20061236.16700-0.4199933.00000
Elliott Maddox1974-1976210730.2994157.51978-19803351024.255762.6
Cameron Maybin201982239.2851191.62021928.03601-0.3
Lee Mazzilli198237128.266620.31976-19899793013.2646815212.5
Billy McKinney2018-202350132.227610.120213991.220510.3
Doc Medich1972-197520000.0197712.000000.0
Doug Mientkiewicz200772166.277501.4200587275.2401101.1
Gustavo Molina201136.167000.0200827.14300-0.1
Xavier Nady2008-200966256.2701211.0200675265.2641420.6
Eduardo Núñez2010-2013270752.2671048-1.4202022.500010.0
John Olerud200449164.280400.61997-19994761662.31563517.3
Adam Ottavino2019-202050000.02022-2024
Chan Ho Park201050000.0200711.000000.0
Andy Phillips2004-2007203479.2531130.4200845.20000-0.1
Lenny Randle19792039.17900-0.51977-1978268950.2727475.0
Willie Randolph1976-198816946303.2754825154.1199290286.252210.9
Hal Reniff1961-196725048.10400-0.31967294.00000-0.1
Joely Rodríguez202130000.0202220000.0
Kenny Rogers1996-199723.000000.019991225.12000-0.1
Rafael Santana1988148480.24041-0.61984-19874831514.248821.5
Gary Sheffield2004-20063471308.29176208.72009100268.2761020.3
Bill Short19601015.200000.11968342.000000.0
Chasen Shreve2015-2018102.000000.02020-202210000.0
Charley Smith1967-1968181495.2241001.21964-1965262942.2423642.8
Shane Spencer1998-20023451091.2634354.0200474185.281460.4
Roy Staiger1979411.273000.01975-1977148446.226442.2
Mike Stanton1997-2005305.200000.12003-20041283.333000.0
Kelly Stinnett20063479.22810-0.21994-2006131358.229640.1
Darryl Strawberry1995-1999231662.25541162.91983-199011093903.26325219136.6
Tom Sturdivant1955-1959115174.218000.61964161.000000.0
Bill Sudakis197489259.23270-0.419721849.14310-0.2
Anthony Swarzak201640000.02018270000.0
Ron Swoboda1971-1973152294.235400.31965-19707372212.24269207.0
Gary Sánchez2015-20215381932.230138411.7202336.16700-0.1
Rey Sánchez1997-200561181.304100.3200356174.20701-1.0
Tony Tarasco19991431.16101-0.520026096.250620.7
Stephen Tarpley2018-2019202110000.0
Ralph Terry1956-1964210394.15500-1.21966-1967136.167000.0
Ryan Thompson20003350.260300.21992-1995283997.2393983.4
Marv Throneberry1955-1959141344.2381520.21962-1963130371.2401610.1
Dick Tidrow1974-197910000.01984110000.0
Mike Torrez19771983-19844875.08000-0.6
Bubba Trammell20032255.20000-0.120003656.232310.0
Robin Ventura2002-2003230748.2493635.51999-20014441513.26077611.0
José Vizcaíno200073174.276050.21994-19963341282.2827182.3
Neil Walker2018113347.219110-0.12016-2017186677.2753333.5
Claudell Washington1986-1990315982.27726343.8198079284.27510170.1
Allen Watson1999-200010000.019991310.300000.0
David Weathers1996-19972002-20041694.00000-0.1
Gerald Williams1992-2002384659.24118211.02004-200596159.23354-0.3
Mason Williams2015-20172564.28112-0.220211733.212100.0
Justin Wilson2015-202160000.02019-2020400000.0
Gene Woodling1949-19546982272.285511316.2196281190.274500.4
Chris Young2014-2015163389.2571742.0201488254.205870.1
Eric Young Jr.201661.00001-0.12013-2015209662.2392712.1
Todd Zeile200366186.21060-0.42000-20044411423.2594142.7

Pitching

  • 83 players pitched for each of these franchises.
Pitching Table
New York Yankees New York Mets
Name Yrs G IP W L SV ERA WAR Yrs G IP W L SV ERA WAR
David Aardsma201211.00009.000.020134339.22204.31-0.1
Juan Acevedo20032525.20367.71-1.019972547.23103.590.1
Jack Aker1969-1972124197.11610312.235.619742441.12123.480.5
Neil Allen1985-198866171.16413.622.71979-1983223381.22540693.543.7
Jason Anderson2003-20052526.12005.470.02003610.20005.060.0
Luis Avilán2020108.10004.320.120194532.04005.060.1
Luis Ayala20115256.02202.091.320081918.01295.50-0.3
Anthony Banda202220.200040.50-0.1202157.11007.36-0.3
Jacob Barnes202211.20000.000.120211918.21126.27-0.4
Armando Benítez200399.11101.930.21999-2003333347.018141602.709.8
Dellin Betances2011-2019358381.22122362.3611.42020-20211612.20107.82-0.3
Phil Bickford202455.000014.40-0.320232525.13214.620.0
Tim Burke19922327.22203.250.11991-19925071.14513.410.3
Ray Burris19791527.21306.18-0.91979-198033192.071503.941.3
John Candelaria1988-198935206.0161013.802.51987312.12005.84-0.1
Chris Capuano2014-201534106.12705.67-0.9201133186.0111204.550.8
Buddy Carlyle201187.20104.700.02014-20153839.02112.310.6
Miguel Castro20223429.05004.03-0.32020-20217979.14603.520.7
Tyler Clippard2007-20177588.26934.670.320153232.14123.060.3
Bartolo Colon201129164.181004.001.52014-201698588.2443403.904.7
David Cone1995-2000145922.0644003.9120.31987-20031871209.1815113.1319.4
Octavio Dotel20061410.000010.80-0.519991985.18305.380.2
Dock Ellis1976-197735231.118903.071.419791785.03706.04-1.1
Scott Erickson2006911.10007.94-0.4200428.00107.88-0.3
Kyle Farnsworth2006-2008181170.16974.331.620141917.00333.180.2
Bob Friend19661244.21404.84-0.319662286.05814.40-0.5
Rob Gardner1970-197223107.19503.190.01965-196646161.241014.79-0.4
Paul Gibson1993-19965468.23104.060.51992-19935170.21205.22-0.7
Dwight Gooden1996-200067341.1241424.675.21984-19943052169.21578513.1041.6
Lee Guetterman1988-1992233347.12119213.734.019924343.13425.82-0.9
Greg Harris199435.00105.40-0.219811668.23514.460.2
LaTroy Hawkins20083341.01105.710.020137270.232132.930.6
Sean Henn2005-20073657.12607.53-1.2201342.20103.380.1
Félix Heredia2003-20045953.21204.860.2200532.20000.000.1
Orlando Hernández1998-2004139876.1614013.9619.02006-200747264.1181203.883.9
Rich Hill2014145.10001.690.220211363.11403.840.7
Ryota Igarashi201223.000012.00-0.12010-20117969.05205.74-1.0
Brandon Knight2001-20021119.100010.71-0.72008412.01005.250.0
Aaron Laffey20111110.22103.380.22013410.00007.20-0.3
Tim Leary1990-199277425.2183505.120.51981-19842366.14403.80-0.1
Al Leiter1987-200538169.0111305.170.41998-20042131360.0956703.4228.0
Cory Lidle20061045.14305.160.519975481.27223.530.4
Graeme Lloyd1996-199810992.14313.511.120033635.11203.310.5
Bob MacDonald19953346.11104.860.319962019.00204.26-0.1
Josías Manzanillo19951117.10002.080.41993-19996794.04424.210.7
Doc Medich1972-1975111787.0494003.4011.2197717.00103.860.1
Dale Murray1983-198562120.03614.73-0.71978-1979111183.1121394.27-0.8
C.J. Nitkowski20041913.01107.62-0.2200155.21000.000.2
Darren O'Day20211210.20003.380.3200943.00000.000.0
Bob Ojeda199423.000024.00-0.41986-1990140764.0514003.129.6
Jesse Orosco2003154.100010.38-0.41979-1987372595.247471072.7312.3
Adam Ottavino2019-20209784.28822.762.12022-2024166161.0812163.023.3
John Pacella1982310.00107.20-0.21977-198039104.13604.83-0.4
Juan Padilla2004611.10003.970.220052436.13111.491.4
Chan Ho Park20102735.12105.60-0.5200714.001015.75-0.3
Jeff Reardon1994119.21028.38-0.31979-198197159.2109102.652.9
Tim Redding200511.001054.00-0.3200930120.03605.100.1
Hal Reniff1961-1967247428.11820413.263.819672943.03343.350.2
Royce Ring201052.100015.43-0.22005-20062623.10203.470.4
David Robertson2008-2018501498.03822532.7512.920234044.042142.051.9
Joely Rodríguez20212119.01002.840.320225550.12404.47-0.2
Kenny Rogers1996-199761324.0181505.113.519991276.05104.031.2
Dennis Santana20242327.12026.26-0.52023910.21005.91-0.1
Don Schulze1989211.01104.090.11987521.21206.23-0.3
Luis Severino2015-2023141727.1543703.7911.920241697.15203.421.4
Bill Short19601047.03504.79-0.319683429.20314.85-0.8
Chasen Shreve2015-2018180174.214623.921.62020-20224251.12105.26-0.1
Mike Stanton1997-2005456448.13114153.778.82003-2004133122.141353.681.4
Marcus Stroman202418100.27403.581.42019-202144238.2141503.214.7
Tom Sturdivant1955-1959115524.1362553.196.119641628.20015.97-0.5
Anthony Swarzak20162631.01205.52-0.120182926.10246.15-0.5
Frank Tanana1993319.20203.200.2199329183.071504.480.7
Stephen Tarpley2018-20193133.21025.88-0.3202110.00000.0
Walt Terrell19891383.06505.20-0.41982-198457369.2192303.534.0
Ralph Terry1956-19642101198.0785993.449.61966-19671328.00114.180.2
Dick Tidrow1974-1979211711.14133233.614.619841115.20009.19-0.8
Michael Tonkin20242331.02111.160.9202457.01205.14-0.8
Mike Torrez197731217.0141203.822.41983-198448260.0112204.47-0.2
Raúl Valdés201166.20002.700.220103858.23314.91-0.3
Allen Watson1999-20003856.14005.270.819991439.22214.080.5
David Weathers1996-19972126.10309.57-1.02002-2004180198.2121273.223.3
Wally Whitehurst199628.01106.750.01989-1992127310.0112233.832.3
Justin Wilson2015-20219579.06104.101.02019-20206858.26342.911.4

What is Immaculate Grid?

Immaculate Grid is a daily trivia game powered by Sports Reference.

Is there an Immaculate Grid game for basketball, football, hockey and soccer?

Yes, Sports Reference has Immaculate Grid games for Men's Basketball, Women's Basketball, Football, Hockey and Soccer as well as Baseball.

How do you play Immaculate Grid?

To play Immaculate Grid, you choose nine players to fill a grid. The grid is laid out as three rows and three columns. You select a player for each cell that matches the criteria for that cell's row and column. You have nine guesses to fill out the grid. Each guess, whether correct or incorrect, counts as a guess.

There is a new grid every day at 6:00 am ET.

See the full rules for more.