This is our old blog. It hasn't been active since 2011. Please see the link above for our current blog or click the logo above to see all of the great data and content on this site.

Most players getting exactly one hit in a game

Posted by Andy on March 25, 2010

Here's a simple search looking at performances for any one team within a game.

First up, here are the top performances in terms of the most players getting exactly one hit. (As a reminder, game finder searches now utilize box scores from the years 1920-1939 and 1952-present., so those are the years covered here.)

Rk Tm Opp Date #Matching
1 NYM CHC 1977-09-18 (2) 12
2 CHW OAK 1970-09-07 (2) 12
3 NYG MLN 1955-06-08 12
4 STL BSN 1923-07-11 12
5 LAD CIN 2009-08-30 11
6 SFG COL 2006-09-18 11
7 BOS OAK 2005-09-18 11
8 ATL ARI 1998-09-20 11
9 CHC STL 1997-09-17 11
10 MIN NYY 1997-08-10 11
11 FLA COL 1996-08-15 11
12 MIN CLE 1996-07-13 11
13 MIN MIL 1990-05-13 11
14 TOR KCR 1983-07-12 11
15 LAD CIN 1983-06-10 11
16 STL NYM 1979-09-28 (2) 11
17 KCR OAK 1977-06-25 11
18 LAD CHC 1960-06-03 11
19 PIT MLN 1957-05-03 11
20 CHW BOS 1936-04-28 11
21 CIN NYG 1931-06-28 (1) 11
22 DET CHW 1930-09-27 (1) 11
23 STL BSN 1920-09-18 (2) 11
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 3/25/2010.

The first two games on the list above have the further distinction that not only did 12 players get exactly one hit for their team but nobody else on the team got more than 1 hit. In other words, everybody got either 1 hit or no hits.

The topmost game, Mets-Cubs in 1977, is even more noteworthy because 4 Cubs got exactly one hit and no other Cubs got a hit.

I wonder if this is the highest combined total for two teams in a game. For starters, here are the 21 games that, across two teams, feature at least 17 different players getting exactly one hit:

Rk Tm Opp Date #Matching
1 LAD SFG 1984-09-29 19
2 ATL SDP 1984-09-29 19
3 HOU PHI 1988-07-23 18
4 LAD CIN 1985-10-06 18
5 LAD CIN 1983-06-10 18
6 MLN PIT 1965-08-22 18
7 STL BSN 1923-07-11 18
8 FLA STL 2003-04-27 17
9 PHI LAD 1999-05-01 17
10 LAD SFG 1998-09-19 17
11 HOU ATL 1995-08-29 17
12 NYM CHC 1987-08-06 17
13 MIN CHW 1983-09-21 (2) 17
14 TEX TOR 1982-05-14 17
15 NYM STL 1979-09-28 (2) 17
16 LAD HOU 1977-09-30 17
17 PHI NYM 1975-09-20 17
18 OAK TEX 1975-09-16 (2) 17
19 MON ATL 1971-05-20 17
20 PIT CHC 1933-05-30 (2) 17
21 PIT STL 1928-05-30 (2) 17
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 3/25/2010.

By looking at the individual box scores, we can find that the record (at least for the years covered in this search) is in fact 18, in the 1983 Dodgers-Reds game (#5 on the list above) where 11 Dodgers and 7 Reds contributed exactly one hit each to the game total of 18.

Among the games with 17 players to get a hit, one of the (Oakland vs Texas in 1975) featured exactly 17 total hits.

All in all, this is not a particularly meaningful search. It's just the sort of thing that's pretty easy to do with the recent improvements to the Play Index.

One Response to “Most players getting exactly one hit in a game”

  1. DMoney Says:

    The top two games happened on the same day...that's just strange. Also, every single starter was subbed out for the Padres in their game (to rest them for the playoffs). Is there any way to see how many times this has happened when NOT dealing with a team that has clinched a playoff spot?