This is our old blog. It hasn't been active since 2011. Please see the link above for our current blog or click the logo above to see all of the great data and content on this site.

Card of the Week: 1995 Leaf Limited #89 John Valentin

Posted by Andy on June 19, 2010

(click on images for larger versions)

Leaf started out in the 1980s as the Canadian version of Donruss. Starting in 1985, Donruss produced a mirror set with some modifications under the Leaf name to be released just in Canada. By the 1990s, though, Leaf became more of a premium edition card set. It wasn't a simple mirror of the base Donruss release nor was it limited to just Canada.

Still, most old-school collectors immediately think of Canada when they hear the name "Leaf" and that makes the design of this card, clearly invoking the American flag, ironic.

Overall I am fond of the design of this card. Yeah, there is a lot of red and there are a lot of stripes. But they used many different colors in the set and did a great job matching card colors to team colors. Each card featured a whopping 3 unique photos, which is simply fantastic, especially since one was a posed head shot and the other two were action shots. Look, for example, at Jay Buhner's card from this set, which features two great action shots and an interesting head shot, all with a great navy and green color scheme that matched that year's Mariners colors.

This card also features some foil, on both the Leaf name on the front and the circular patch on the back. One thing I find weird is the large text that says "Card Number", which seems needless. It mirrors the position text ("Shortstop", in this case) on the left side of the card but still doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

Using the stripes to act as line dividers for the stats on the back was a very nice touch.

Ahh, those stats on the back. Let's take a look at those.

All the way on the right we see Valentin's career stats including both SLG and OBP...nice. What really catches my eye, however, is the monthly split data. Back in 1995, this sort of data was extremely hard to come by unless you tabulated it yourself. Monthly split data has always been interesting to me. I like to see players who are consistent from month to month. All the games count the same so ideally a player should hit the same for the whole season. It seems that a number of players have slow Aprils--Mark Teixeira and Don Mattingly spring to mind--which always bothers me.

Notice how Valentin, through 1994, had 4 to6 homers every month except May, when he had 0 career homers in 95 AB?

Here are his career splits by month, 1992-2002:

I Split G AB H HR RBI BA OBP SLG
April/March 149 551 127 14 61 .230 .310 .374
May 185 675 190 20 98 .281 .364 .452
June 203 722 205 26 104 .284 .359 .467
July 191 673 207 21 101 .308 .390 .504
August 206 728 208 22 106 .286 .363 .459
Sept/Oct 171 568 156 21 88 .275 .360 .456
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 6/18/2010.

He caught up with his May numbers thanks in large part to 7 homers in May of 1995.

That brings me to John Valentin's 1995.

Check out the leaders in Wins Above Replacement (among batters) for 1995:

Rk Player WAR/pos Tm G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS BA OBP SLG OPS Pos
1 John Valentin 8.5 BOS 135 621 520 108 155 37 2 27 102 81 67 20 5 .298 .399 .533 .931 *6
2 Edgar Martinez 7.7 SEA 145 639 511 121 182 52 0 29 113 116 87 4 3 .356 .479 .628 1.107 *D/53
3 Barry Bonds 7.3 SFG 144 635 506 109 149 30 7 33 104 120 83 31 10 .294 .431 .577 1.009 *7
4 Tim Salmon 6.8 CAL 143 638 537 111 177 34 3 34 105 91 111 5 5 .330 .429 .594 1.024 *9/D
5 Reggie Sanders 6.7 CIN 133 567 484 91 148 36 6 28 99 69 122 36 12 .306 .397 .579 .975 *98
6 Albert Belle 6.6 CLE 143 629 546 121 173 52 1 50 126 73 80 5 2 .317 .401 .690 1.091 *7/D
7 Craig Biggio 6.6 HOU 141 673 553 123 167 30 2 22 77 80 85 33 8 .302 .406 .483 .889 *4
8 Chuck Knoblauch 6.5 MIN 136 629 538 107 179 34 8 11 63 78 95 46 18 .333 .424 .487 .911 *4/6
9 Mike Piazza 6.3 LAD 112 475 434 82 150 17 0 32 93 39 80 1 0 .346 .400 .606 1.006 *2
10 Bernie Williams 6.0 NYY 144 648 563 93 173 29 9 18 82 75 98 8 6 .307 .392 .487 .878 *8
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/18/2010.

Yup.Valentin was never an All-Star and finished 9th in the AL in MVP voting in 1995. Valentin finished first in WAR by putting together very solid seasons both with the bat and in the field at shortstop.

7 Responses to “Card of the Week: 1995 Leaf Limited #89 John Valentin”

  1. Mike Says:

    That is one of the ugliest baseball cards I've ever seen.

  2. Al Says:

    Weird, I just discovered Valentin's amazing '95 last night. As an Indians fan, I torture myself every once in a while by reviewing how Belle's season was better than that of '95 MVP Mo Vaughn. However, it looks like a member of the Red Sox may have deserved that year's award after all; just not the one who got it.

  3. Michael E Sullivan Says:

    The question as you asked it yesterday has another answer, which was a bit easier to guess: Greg Maddux.

    I was shocked when confirming that to see that JV had the highest WAR for the AL or all non-pitchers. I knew he'd had a few good seasons back then, but did not expect him to be the answer here. A lot of fielding war in that number.

  4. Frank Clingenpeel Says:

    I was surprised about Valentin, but I thought you were talking about Tom Glavine. And I was thinking -- wrong, I will admit -- that Edgar Martinez would've been the leader in WAR.

  5. Andy Says:

    So Frank, why did you post on the other thread that you got both players? What reference were you checking against--your own memory?

  6. Frank Clingenpeel Says:

    I checked the yearly leader boards on this site -- I thought. That's where I camew up with Maddox and Martinez.

  7. Frank Clingenpeel Says:

    Andy,

    I am due to make a business trip next week, but when I return, I hope I can learn how to read these data better. Are you ready to start tutoring a 74-year-old ignoramous?